Imagine strolling through a Minnetonka garage sale in 2016, when an antique collector stumbled upon an intriguing oil painting of a fisherman mending his net, pipe in mouth, and thought it was worth the $50 price tag. Little did they know, this modest purchase might be a long-lost masterpiece by Vincent van Gogh, potentially valued at $15 million.
The painting, now dubbed “Elimar” due to an inscription in the corner, depicts a bearded fisherman engrossed in his work by the sea. Experts believe it dates back to 1889, during Van Gogh’s stay at the Saint-Paul psychiatric asylum in Saint-Rémy-de-Provence, France—a period when he created iconic works like “The Starry Night.”
In 2019, the New York-based art research firm LMI Group International acquired “Elimar” and embarked on a meticulous four-year investigation to determine its authenticity. Their comprehensive 450-page report involved a team of 20 experts, including art historians, scientists, and conservators. They conducted pigment analysis, historical research, and even DNA testing on a red hair found embedded in the paint. While the DNA was too degraded for conclusive results, it was identified as belonging to a human male, adding an intriguing layer to the mystery.
One compelling aspect of their research is the theory that “Elimar” is a “translation” by Van Gogh—a reinterpretation of another artist’s work. Van Gogh admired Danish painter Michael Ancher and may have been inspired by Ancher’s depictions of fishermen. This aligns with Van Gogh’s known practice of creating works that were not direct copies but personal interpretations, or “translations,” of existing pieces.
However, the path to authentication is filled with challenges. The Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam, renowned for its expertise, previously examined “Elimar” and did not attribute it to Van Gogh, citing stylistic discrepancies. Despite this, LMI Group remains optimistic, planning to present their findings to Van Gogh scholars in hopes of securing official recognition.
The art world is no stranger to such debates. Authenticating artworks, especially those of a prolific and studied artist like Van Gogh, requires a delicate balance of scientific analysis and scholarly consensus. The story of “Elimar” serves as a captivating reminder of the mysteries that still linger in art history and the potential treasures hidden in the most unexpected places.
So, next time you’re perusing a garage sale or thrift store, take a closer look at that dusty old painting. Who knows? You might just discover a masterpiece waiting to be unveiled.
Canvas For Painting - Custom Size 
Leave a comment